Shortly after leaving university, I went to live in an experimental Christian community that was a mite dysfunctional. In my bewilderment, I was downloading at Donald Reeves, then Rector of St. James' Picadilly who suggested there were two forms a successful religious community could take. The first was to be rooted in a clear set of rules, a sanctioned hierarchy, and an evolving tradition. His example of such a community was a Benedictine monastery (in which, in passing, Thomas Merton thought the only place in which one could practice communism). The second type was where the processes of life were a continuing negotiation rooted in shared practices of dialogue that allowed for a flatter structure and enabled frissons to be (endlessly) negotiated. His example of such a community was the then relatively newly formed Findhorn in Scotland. Do not, he suggested, fall between these two stools - as evidently where I was living did! I was reminded of this sage advice when reading Anna Ne...